Why smiling can make you look older in a photo
A smile feels youthful. But the age you assign to a particular photo is a separate question. Experiments have produced a surprisingly different answer.
An AgeGuessr explainer · Published
Same person, different expression
In a 2015 study, Tzvi Ganel compared age judgments of smiling and neutral photographs of the same people. Smiling faces were judged older. His proposed explanation was that observers take account of the wrinkles that form around the eyes during a smile.
Sources: [1]
The age of the face matters
A 2021 study replicated the effect for faces aged 20–39, but did not find it for faces aged 60–79. For the 40–59 group, it appeared for male faces but not female faces. So “a smile always adds years” is too broad a rule.
Sources: [2]
What to do with this finding
Imagine choosing between two profile pictures: a neutral expression and a broad smile. If you would assign an older age to the second picture, that does not mean the person has changed. The photograph you are judging has changed.
For a guessing game, the useful question is which detail led to your answer. Before choosing a number, try naming that detail. Was it the expression, the overall face, or just your first impression? Reviewing the decision can make a miss easier to understand, although it does not guarantee a more accurate next guess.
Watch your own eye for age
On the next smiling photo, make your own age estimate first. After seeing the answer, consider whether your guess depended entirely on lines around the eyes. This is a way to reflect on a decision, not a proven method for improving your score.
Research papers
- Smiling makes you look older
Tzvi Ganel · Psychonomic Bulletin & Review · 2015
DOI: 10.3758/s13423-015-0822-7 - The effect of smiling on the perceived age of male and female faces across the lifespan
Tzvi Ganel, Melvyn A. Goodale · Scientific Reports · 2021
DOI: 10.1038/s41598-021-02380-2