Is it easier to guess the age of someone from your own group?
If we recognise familiar kinds of faces more easily, is their age easier to judge too? Researchers have tested this question. The outcome was not the same for every group of observers.
An AgeGuessr explainer · Published
An advantage that was not symmetrical
In a 2001 study by Dehon and Brédart, participants estimated the ages of faces the authors categorised as Caucasian and African. The first participant group performed better with own-group faces; the second showed no such difference. The authors linked this pattern to the African participants’ residence in Belgium, an interpretation rather than a demonstrated cause.
Sources: [1]
Culture may matter too
In a 2010 study, Japanese, Chinese and Asian-Canadian participants chose the older of two East Asian faces. For middle-aged faces, the Japanese group was fastest after accounting for accuracy. The authors related differences to cultural practices; the experiment did not establish causality. The task asked “who is older?”, not “how many years old?”.
Sources: [2]
Check what was actually measured
Choosing the older of two faces differs from giving one face a numerical age. You can put people in the right age order yet miss their ages by many years. For example, guesses of 40 and 50 preserve the correct order for people aged 25 and 35, although both guesses are too high. This example is invented.
When comparing studies with a game, check both the task and the outcome: response speed, the proportion of correct comparisons, or a miss measured in years. The same word, “accuracy”, does not make these measures interchangeable.
Watch your own eye for age
After playing, look at the direction of your misses: do you more often guess too high or too low? For personal reflection, use the known age when the photo was taken. You do not need to guess someone’s ethnicity to explain a single miss.
Research papers
- An ‘other-race’ effect in age estimation from faces
Hedwige Dehon, Serge Brédart · Perception · 2001
DOI: 10.1068/p3122 - Culture Shapes Efficiency of Facial Age Judgments
Gizelle Anzures, Liezhong Ge, Zhe Wang, Shoji Itakura, Kang Lee · PLOS ONE · 2010
DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0011679